Supreme Court Allows Limited Version of Trump Travel Ban to Take Effect

Update from Stephen W. Yale-Loehr of Miller Mayer, LLP | June 26, 2017

Today the U.S. Supreme Court decided to hear the government’s appeal of two lower court decisions that had blocked President Trump’s executive order banning travel from six Muslim-majority countries for 90 days and suspending the U.S. refugee program for 120 days. The Supreme Court order today kept in place part of the lower court injunctions, but stayed the lower courts’ decisions for foreign nationals “who lack any bona fide relationship” with U.S. persons. The Supreme Court will hear arguments on the merits of the executive order in October.

The Supreme Court’s order is a partial win for the Trump administration, but will be confusing to implement over the summer. According to the order, the administration cannot block entry of individuals from the six affected countries (Libya, Iran, Somalia, Sudan, Syria, and Yemen) and refugees from around the world if they have “a credible claim of a bona fide relationship with a person or entity in the United States.” How individuals will prove such a relationship, and whether the burden of proof will be on the government or the individuals seeking entry, remains to be seen.

The Court’s order provided the following examples of bona fide relationships:

“The facts of these cases illustrate the sort of relationship that qualifies. For individuals, a close familial relationship is required. A foreign national who wishes to enter the United States to live with or visit a family member . . . clearly has such a relationship. As for entities, the relationship must be formal, documented, and formed in the ordinary course, rather than for the purpose of evading [the executive order]. The students from the designated countries who have been admitted to the University of Hawaii have such a relationship with an American entity. So too would a worker who accepted an offer of employment from an American company or a lecturer invited to address an American audience. Not so someone who enters into a relationship simply to avoid [the executive order]. For example, a nonprofit group devoted to immigration issues may not contact foreign nationals from the designated countries, add them to client lists, and then secure their entry by claiming injury from their exclusion.”

Based on those examples, an international student from one of the six affected countries who is already in the United States should be able to leave for the summer and return. Similarly, a refugee who has an established relationship with a U.S. refugee resettlement agency should be allowed to enter the United States. But much may be left up to the discretion of State Department consular officers at U.S. embassies and consulate, and Customs and Border Protection officers at ports of entry. If an individual is denied a visa or entry, the U.S. relative or entity may need to sue on their behalf.

The case will now go back to the two district courts that originally entered the injunctions. They will have to decide these issues.

The Supreme Court’s order is located here.

Stephen W. Yale-Loehr
Miller Mayer, LLP
215 East State Street, Suite 200
P.O. Box 6435
Ithaca, New York 14851-6435

Yale-Loehr is a Professor of Immigration Law Practice, Cornell Law School and Co-Author of Immigration Law & Procedure Treatise

Refugees Resettled In Chicago Help Make Its Most Famous Cheesecake

NPR | January 3, 2017

Employees hand-finish cheesecakes on the production line at Eli's in Chicago.NPR’s Morning Edition featured a story about the role refugees play at Eli’s Cheesecake, a successful business whose workforce is staffed with about 15% refugees.

Ailing Vermont Town Pins Hopes on Mideast Refugees

The New York Times | January 2, 2017

Ailing Vermont Town Pins Hopes on Mideast RefugeesA remote city in Vermont is turning to refugees as an opportunity to revitalize a declining population and economy. “We need people,” says Mayor Christopher Louras: “[This is] an opportunity to grow our population, bring in individuals, families, new Americans from Syria who have a strong work ethic, who were fleeing for their lives and looking to rebuild those shattered lives.”

Maeve in America

First Look Media/Panoply | December 27, 2016

Maeve in America“With all this talk about wall building, bad hombres and refugees as Skittles, comedian Maeve Higgins is beyond ready to change the conversation around immigration. She’s traveled all the way here from Ireland to bring you funny, beautiful and sometimes maddening immigration stories, told by the people who’ve lived them.”

Why Catholic Charities is aiding refugees

Ithaca Journal | December 1, 2016

Kathleen BerginKathleen Bergin, community liaison for Catholic Charities Tompkins-Tioga, reflects on why Catholic Charities, as well as many organizations in Ithaca, are committed to their efforts in welcoming refugees.

The Syrians Next Door

Time Magazine | November 3, 2016

Mike Rother, a welder and Trump supporter who lives across the street, says he had misgivings about living near Syrians but has come to realize his worry was misplaced. “Obviously, they’re not bringing anything but children playing outside,” he says. “I see kids kicking a soccer ball, riding their bikes, playing with each other. They wave to me and say ‘Hi’ and want to pet my dog.”

For Helping Immigrants, Chobani’s Founder Draws Threats

The New York Times | October 31, 2016

NYT Chobani“He’s the xenophobe’s nightmare,” Mr. Roth said. “Here’s an immigrant who isn’t competing for jobs, but is creating jobs big time. It runs completely counter to the far-right narrative.”

Road to Refuge: What does it take to come to Ithaca as a refugee?

The Ithaca Voice | August 20, 2016

Melissa Whitworth continues her series with an explanation of the intricate vetting process people undergo when requesting refugee status, the federal and local support they receive, and the organizations that care for them upon their arrival in Ithaca.

What Does It Mean to Help One Family?

The New York Times | September 8, 2016

NYT Help One FamilyHere’s a thought provoking piece from The New York Times about the bittersweet moments refugees and their new communities experience.

Let’s welcome refugees, because we need them

The Post Star | August 18, 2016

Post Star LogoGlen Falls, NY resident Will Doolittle writes a column calling for refugee resettlement in his city and points out the various benefits cities of similar size and circumstances have enjoyed from welcoming refugees.